Tuesday, February 26, 2013

SeCrit #3 (First 250 Words)

Title: SIGHTLESS
Genre: YA Urban Fantasy
A warm flush crept up Carly’s neck and onto her face as the crowd in the Flying Owl pressed in on her, their sweat and perfume becoming her own. She edged her way through the throng, pressing against damp backs and oversized purses until she came to a clearing near the bar. Leaning against the wall, she wiped her forehead. Her fingers came away shiny with sweat and make-up.
The voices around her morphed into a single yell as the band walked on stage. Carly tried to catch Tyler’s eye, but he bent over his amp, a crease between his eyes. She knew that nervous look, and it twisted her insides to see it now.
Despite the heat, a cool tingle crept up Carly’s spine. The people around her were looking everywhere but at her, but she couldn’t shake the feeling that she was being watched. She wrapped her arms around herself and searched the crowd. A moment later, the sea of people parted, and Carly locked eyes with a woman leaning against the bar.
Carly searched her face for some sign of familiarity. The woman stood up straight, and Carly saw that she was wearing skintight leather pants, a low-cut red shirt, and black, high-heeled boots. Hardly the wardrobe of a security guard.
           The corners of the woman’s mouth slowly curled into a knowing smile. Carly shivered. A yell went up around her and the crowd closed in around Carly once more.
 Critique:

A warm flush crept up Carly’s neck and onto her face as the crowd in the Flying Owl pressed in on her, their sweat and perfume becoming her own. She edged her way through the throng, pressing against damp backs and oversized purses until she came to a clearing near the bar. Leaning against the wall, she wiped her forehead. Her fingers came away shiny with sweat and make-up. Okay, here's what I get from this first paragraph: She's in a bar and it's hot. The setting itself is fine, but pretty much every sentence mentions or alludes to sweat. To me, that's over-describing just one aspect of the setting. What does this bar and its people feel like, not just physically, but what is the vibe? I get that the bar is packed, but from this description, I imagine a lot of sweaty people standing around. Is that what's happening? I would expect there to be a lot of talking, yelling for drinks, maybe dancing? Also, what is she doing there? I know you start to tell us that in the next paragraph, but you have plenty of opportunity to do it now and really hook me.
The voices around her morphed into a single yell as the band walked on stage. Carly tried to catch Tyler’s eye, but he bent over his amp, a crease between his eyes (do you mean “between his eyebrows”? Between his eyes seems awkward to me. Also, I wouldn't mind a tiny bit more description of Tyler here. Especially if he's the love interest ;) ). She knew that nervous look, and it twisted her insides to see it now. (I like this. I think it shows a lot about the character and the situation in few words. Well done.)
Despite the heat, a cool tingle crept up Carly’s spine. The people around her were looking everywhere but at her, but she couldn’t shake the feeling that she was being watched. She wrapped her arms around herself and searched the crowd. A moment later, the sea of people parted, and Carly locked eyes (“locked eyes” is kind of a cliché saying. Try using your voice to put your own spin on this, maybe?) with a woman leaning against the bar.
Carly searched (watch out for repeating words) her face for some sign of familiarity. The woman stood up straight, and Carly saw that she (you don't really need to tell us this. We know Carly's the one doing the seeing) was wearing (instead of "was wearing" how about "wore"?) skintight leather pants, a low-cut red shirt, and black, high-heeled boots. Hardly the wardrobe of a security guard. (Why are we assuming she's a security guard? This sentence seems to come out of nowhere.)
           The corners of the woman’s mouth slowly curled into a knowing smile. Carly shivered (I feel like I want more here as to why Carly is creeped out by this woman. She doesn't seem too creepy to me.). A yell (I highlighted “yell” here and earlier because you use it for the same thing. I want more of your voice, more description. Was it a frenzied scream? A collective chant of the band's name?) went up around her and the crowd closed in around Carly once more.
Notice how many times the character's name is said? This is one of those things I find tricky about third person. Knowing when to use the character's name and when not to. I think you've used it too much here. 

So, there you have it folks. Thanks to everyone who submitted and special thanks to the author of this submission! I think you have a great start, you just need to allow yourself to embellish, have fun with the words! And remember, folks, we want to encourage all of you to add your own thoughts in the comments!

7 secret replies:

  1. Kudos to the author but putting their story out there to be crit'd :) I agree with what's been pointed out here. I was also very thrown by the security guard part. Best of luck!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, very awesome of this authors to let us critique their work! Thanks for commenting Scarlet!

      Delete
  2. I'd like to see a first sentence that snags me and reels me in. Your first sentence (or sentences) is a great opportunity to set the tone for the chapter, character, and ms. I think you can get a lot more out of it than is there now.

    What do your first 250 tell us about Carly that might intrigue us to keep reading? In my opinion, that's the fact that she's being watched. I'd start with the watching, then as you describe the scene and the crowd, feather in how uncomfortable she is, seemingly for no reason, as she tries to enjoy her fave band. I don't know if I'd mention the woman in red yet, but that's up to you.

    Can you describe the crowd in a way that lets us into Carly's head a little more? How comfortable is she in this group-- does she thrive on the crowds or does she feel suffocated by them? Giving us a little more insight by the way that Carly describes things/reacts to them is a great way to tell us what kind of a person she is without explicitly saying so.

    Definitely agree with Leah to have fun with words! :) You have a scene with a bunch of potential here-- play it up!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well said, Alex. Especially the part about letting us into Carly's head more. Totally agree with that. Thanks for commenting and helping out!!!

      Delete
  3. It seems like you were trying to build tension primarily through the setting (crowd, perfume, sweat, noise). SOME of that is great (and you found some really creative ways to describe the atmosphere), but as a reader, I want more tension coming straight from your character. I want to get inside Carly's head, not just see the bar through her eyes. Of whom or what is she afraid? Along those same lines, I want to know more about her relationship with Tyler. What distinguishes them from any other musician and his girl? Also, what's at stake here? We've got Carly in a bar, feeling all paranoid, and this curiously clad security guard, but I really don't know enough about Carly to be on her side yet. I don't need to know EVERYTHING about her, but give me a few reasons to know she's a character worth cheering.

    Kudos to you for getting your work out there. For me, the first few pages - that awkward place where people are deciding whether or not to invest in the rest of the story - are especially hard to open up to critical eyes.

    Best of luck as you go forward!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Good job submitting and being critiqued. It is always a little scary! Overall, I like the piece. The writing is easy to read which is a huge plus!

    I did have to reread the first sentence a few times to get the setting, for some reason I kept reading Flying Owl and picturing a group of jet fighters. That's probably my own stupidity though. I wasn't grounded into what type of story this was, I imagine if I'd read a back cover blurb already that wouldn't be an issue at all.

    I do want to know more about this woman watching Carly. She didn't seem strange at all so why Carly is so freaked by her I didn't grasp. I know it is only 250 words but it just felt out of place or under explained. I knew more about the collective group sweat than the strange woman.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I've just found this blog. I don't have any critique to add to this but wanted to say what a great learning tool! My WIP is written in 3rd person and I also struggle with how frequently to use the MC's first name versus a pronoun. I can't wait to read future critiques.

    ReplyDelete